Autism

Autism in Brazil Part I

Published April 22, 2009 @ 09:54AM PT

[Ed. this is part of the International Perspectives series.]

the flag of brazil, a green field with ahorizontal yellow diamond on it; in the center of the diamond is a blue circle with stars and the words in blue on a white background 'ordem progresso'You may have seen that old movie Change of Habit, where Elvis Presley "cures" an autistic girl just by holding her tenderly. In that 1969 flick, Elvis was a doctor who believed the child was withdrawn because she had been neglected by her parents. Growing up in Brazil in the 70's and 80's, we watched several repeats of that movie on TV. So that false stereotype is the image of autism that first comes to mind for many people of my generation. In a country where psychoanalysis is still very popular, it is not an easy feat to spread awareness that autism is not caused by bad parenting, but by genetic, biological factors. Still, starting in the 1990's, parents of autistic children have made tremendous progress by creating associations and foundations throughout the country, in order to provide information for the public and even treatment--from ABA and TEACCH to residential options for severely affected adults.

The Federal Government has just started to promote some awareness by recently creating an agency in Defense of People with Special Needs (CORDE) under the Human Rights Secretary. However, there are hardly any governmental programs devoted to autism treatment, except for a few psychiatric facilities and State grants given to parents' associations that offer clinics for people with autism and other disabilities. The most influential of these associations is AMA-Sao Paulo (the acronym in Portuguese reads like the word "LOVES" and it stands for Association of Friends of the Autistic), located in Brazil's largest city (population: 19 million).

AMA currently offers free therapy for 150 autistic children and teens, mostly ABA- and TEACCH-based, and residential placements. A new branch that will focus on therapy and job training for the severely autistic is slated to open this year. The waiting list in their clinics has people from all over the country and is over one-year long. There are only 50,000 people officially diagnosed with autism in Brazil at the moment, but specialists consider this number grossly underestimated, and that is due to a lack of national studies on incidence/prevalence of the disorder, plus insufficient reporting and awareness from doctors that see autistic kids nationwide. If actual autism rates don't seem to vary from one country to the other, Brazil could have more than 1 million autistics, given that the total population is now over 183 million people.

That's one of the reasons why AMA established a partnership with the Sao Paulo School of Medicine where they promote autism education for Med students specializing in Psychiatry. "We have many doctors in the largest cities that are updated in the latest autism studies, but the majority is still lacking knowledge on the disorder and its diagnosis", says Ana Maria Serrajordia de Melo, who founded AMA in 1983, when she realized there were not enough resources available to treat and educate her severely autistic son (now 30 years old). As a naval engineer, she had no previous experience in the autism field, but she got educated, even taking courses abroad, and joined forces with other parents who were also trying to improve the situation of autism families in Brazil.

But as much as AMA-Sao Paulo is doing a great job, it can't serve thousands of cases nationwide. The situation is more critical for families with severely autistic adults who are not accepted in public institutions and who can't afford--or live very far away from00the few private residential facilities available. Rio de Janeiro, the second largest city in the country, has just opened its first county clinic for autism, trying to give autistic people a more differentiated treatment than what they were getting in the public psychiatric hospitals. In the state of Bahia, a very strong parents association fought tooth and nail and was recently able to change the State legislation and ensure treatment for autistic people either in public institutions or private clinics contracted by the State.

Public schools in Brazil have typically very little Special Education resources, but two national charitable, non-profit organizations, Pestalozzi and APAE, have schools for people with intellectual disabilities. Inclusion in mainstream classrooms is a fairly new concept encouraged by the federal government, first by law in 1996, and then through a program that started in 2003 to train teachers and educators in 114 cities. According to psychologist and professor Jose Raimundo Facion, who advocates inclusion, "Brazil's legislation on special ed is good, but the government still doesn't provide enough resources for the schools to make sure that the child will receive adequate education."

Share this Post

Related Posts

Comments (6)

  1. Vanessa Rodrigues

    Hi Leila,

    Thanks for this very interesting article. My thoughts and concerns go especially to those parents that need to rely on the public education service in Brazil. Despite the recent efforts by the different levels of government and by nonprofit organizations, the crude reality – at least from my non-professional perspective – is that public schools are definitely not prepared to receive – and sometimes event to recognize – children with special needs. Brazil is so big that is difficult to imagine how the schools in the tiny cities and villages in the countryside, or in the Amazonian region, for instance, will really benefit from the efforts developed by the government. I don´t want to sound pessimist, but I believe that we need a strong movement of concerned people able to raise their voices to push the government to invest more and better to create a sort of network of reference schools spread all over the country to give the support the autistic and children with other special needs deserve.

    Vanessa

    Posted by Vanessa Rodrigues on 04/22/2009 @ 08:31PM PT

  2. @Vanessa. strong movement of concerned people able to raise their voices.

    @Leila Couceiro.

    A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.Lao-tzu, chinese philosopher. Rather than emphasizing the first step, Lau Tzu regarded action as something that arises naturally from stillness.

    I knew some doctors who went to the Fundacao Esperanca, Inc. in Santarem, Para, Brazil. One was connected with a religious order for several years and the other was a retired physician. Entire villages in the Amazon would save money for a long time so that one child could get needed surgery for cleft palate etc. Brazil is so big and yet I and my friends have aways marveled at the spirit of their people.

    I think you are right, Vanessa. It will take a strong movement of concerned people.

    I also think it is interesting that they use ABA, TEACCH behavioral therapies, employment and long term care. It sounds like they are influenced by what other countries do.

     Maybe Brazilians need more exposure to autism articles based on research in newspapers, internet etc. They could then better understand their options. Just like families of autistic people maybe Brazilians have to feel that it is possible to help others. Autism is a complex problem and sometimes people feel helpless in dealing with it. Also don't forget the power of one family member who is trying to help their child. Sometimes one person can change the world.

    Brazil's current president is Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, from the Partido dos Trabalhadores (Workers' Party), seems very charismatic and popular. Perhaps he could bring change to autism too.

    Although Brazil is at a slower level of services at the moment than the US this could all change. I remember when my son was young there was nothing. Now look what things are like 10 years later in the US.







    Posted by L I on 04/23/2009 @ 11:10AM PT

  3. peter castles

    nice article, leila! i fear it will be a long time before brazil has the awareness and resources to fully tackle autism and other special needs challenges. because early intervention is key in treating spectrum disorders, i hope brazilian advocates, activists, and legislators focus some funding on these programs. leila, are there organizations that could be supported by donations even from abroad?

    Posted by peter castles on 04/26/2009 @ 10:04PM PT

  4. Cris Smith

    Great article! It manages to map, in a concise way, the bleak situation of autism in Brazil. Actually, information is exactly what people need in order to start combating the prejudice that comes hand in hand with most intelectual disorders. I have two daughters that study in private schools in the south of Brazil and was appalled at the lack of knowledge teachers displayed when I told them my daughter had ADHD. Had they known about the disorder, they could have spared us some really unnecessary pain. Ultimately, my daughter herself had to learn how to deal with her teachers's ignorance. So much the better for her but that shouldn't have been the case. Anyway, it is a shame that Brazil is only now taking the very first steps towards an awareness of Austism. Let's hope the situation improves at a more dynamic pace now.

    Posted by Cris Smith on 05/11/2009 @ 04:46PM PT

  5. Cris Smith

    By the way, may I suggest a Brazilian autobiographical novel called "O filho eterno" (2007) by Cristovão Tezza? The already celebrated author talks, for the first time, and without any melodramatic streak, about his son who has down syndrome. It is a beautiful read but it also denounces the nightmarish situation of the disease in Brazil.

    Posted by Cris Smith on 05/11/2009 @ 05:03PM PT

  6. Nina  Sa

    Does anyone happen to know if there are any Brazilain scholars that are working on issues of autism in Brazil, but who are working or studying here in the United States? I am an immigration attorney and have a client with an autistic son, and I am in need of expert testimony/evidence regarding the living/learning conditions for those with autism in Brazil as part of a defense to deprtation. For that matter, I would appreciate contact information for someone in Brazil. Any communication can be sent to nsa@laccm.org

    Posted by Nina Sa on 05/29/2009 @ 11:59AM PT

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

Author

Leila Couceiro, Brazilian expat living in Sacramento, CA. Worked as a journalist when she lived in Rio de Janeiro.

Most Popular Autism Posts
close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.